Previous Ideas and Comment Threads for this board are shown below.
ICDP Data & Samples
Ideas and Comments
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
Comments :
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-28 At 14:54
Studies of legacy cores should consider in situ alteration and biomediated alteration in the repository. The 1979 Surtsey basalt cores have changed in situ over the past 24 years. Especially in volcanic glass characteristics and microborings. What are ideal core storage conditions to preserve reactive rocks?
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-11-02 At 14:43
We have not specifically investigated volcanic glass alterations during storage. Since it easily reacts with water, the best storage might be dry/low humidity. Samples of this sort are e.g. transported in vacuumed and sealed bags but there might be too much water in the core material to begin with for this storage option
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-28 At 14:54
What about the future of IODP/NSF funding directions and strategies?
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-28 At 15:05
Please refer to IODP representatives on this topic (e.g. Henk Brinkhuis, Gilbert Camoin, Nadine Hallmann)
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-28 At 14:51
We need to make sure that key expertise is maintained. Training schools in biostratigraphy and sedimentology are needed.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-28 At 14:50
mDIS has improved and become an excellent tool. The individual projects need, in most cases, to have help in implementing the tool.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
Cindy (ICDP)
2023-09-13 At 08:06
Thank you! We are always here to help and train you. Please do not hesitate to ask!
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-28 At 14:49
Integrated scientific drilling & project management course for ECRs
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-11-05 At 11:51
see comments and discussion under "visibility"
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:49
Subglacial lake systems may offer a "virgin" addition to ICDP future science plans. Real data gap for mid-high latitude areas (i.e. Canada & Australia). Environmental change like "arctic amplification" is happen with a geohazard not addressed.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-23 At 18:01
ICDP is flexible and the ICDP Science Plan not cast in stone. Please submit a pre-proposal if you have identified new scientific targets that require deep scientific drilling, even if these targets are not discussed in the Science Plan.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:45
Data repository for age models, and other data produced
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-23 At 17:57
ICDP only stores the basic dataset for internal use of the project members during the moratorium. ICDP is not a data repository, but we can support you by publishing the basic datasets and help to find a suitable data repository for you.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:44
How can we promote the re-use of cores obtained in previous ICDP-supported projects? Should we support sampling workshops?
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-23 At 17:56
If you want to apply new scientific methods on legacy core, I would recommend to submit a workshop proposal on this!
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:42
Why are ICDP cores only retained for 10 years? We need to retain them indefinitely.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-24 At 14:53
ICDPs funding contract require storage for at least 10 years and state that ICDP will take care for longer storage should a repository close down. Usually core is stored unlimited in time in the core repositories, but this depends also on the respective core repository and the regulations for core handling.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:39
Should ICDP have minimum standard measurements for cores?
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-23 At 17:52
Not all ICDP projects produce cores, and for those that do, cores often remain in the liner (which makes e.g. optical scanning useless) and are later opened in laboratories. Core or at least core catcher sample description is mandatory for projects drilling core.
ICDP already offers a few devices that you can request and use during the drilling. That would need to be included in the costs and timeframe of the project.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:38
Should ICDP have more standartzed drilling project reports like IODP?
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-24 At 15:01
PIs are obliged to publish Operational Reports, which have already some level of standardization. Since ICDP projects are much more diverse than IODP projects, further standardization as in IODP would not be helpful.
However, there is room for improvement and ICDP is striving to get better reports. This depends not only on current efforts but also on enhanced funding by ICDP and other contributing parties.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:37
Does ICDP get any core/data/other things in return for the funding that they provide? It might be useful to get some data from the ICDP website.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-23 At 17:42
Samples and data created by an ICDP-funded project belong to the project and not ICDP. In return to project funding, we expect to be acknowledged or included in your publication.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:35
More ICDP data should adhere to FAIR data guidelines.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-24 At 15:04
ICDP funding requires samples to be stored accessible and data to be made available along FAIR standards. Basic data are often available on the ICDP web, other data are available through different repositories. ICDPs data and sample manager can help in most cases to find these resources and make efforts to improve FINDABLE on ICDP web. Since the COSC-1 project (~2015), ICDP assignes IGSNs to holes, cores, sections, samples.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:34
We need to have a stronger data management plan that conforms to FAIR principles
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-23 At 17:37
ICDP will consider making a data management plan mandatory in ICDP full proposals and provide a template.
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP Conference
2023-08-14 At 17:29
Formalized sample allocation procedure. Currently, there is too much power with a single person (PI, curator...) ,making a decision on their own. Gatekeepers exist!
How about a sample request management module?
Thank you for your idea or comment. Your comment was added successfully.
ICDP
2023-08-23 At 17:33
That is in the hands of the project. We recommend to have a data and sample manager in every project, that stays with the data/samples even after the project has ended. Or the project has to organize that with the core repository. Sample Requests should always be decided upon by the PI-team.
Comments :
Subglacial lake systems may offer a "virgin" addition to ICDP future science plans. Real data gap for mid-high latitude areas (i.e. Canada & Australia). Environmental change like "arctic amplification" is happen with a geohazard not addressed.
ICDP is flexible and the ICDP Science Plan not cast in stone. Please submit a pre-proposal if you have identified new scientific targets that require deep scientific drilling, even if these targets are not discussed in the Science Plan.
ICDP only stores the basic dataset for internal use of the project members during the moratorium. ICDP is not a data repository, but we can support you by publishing the basic datasets and help to find a suitable data repository for you.
If you want to apply new scientific methods on legacy core, I would recommend to submit a workshop proposal on this!
ICDPs funding contract require storage for at least 10 years and state that ICDP will take care for longer storage should a repository close down. Usually core is stored unlimited in time in the core repositories, but this depends also on the respective core repository and the regulations for core handling.
Not all ICDP projects produce cores, and for those that do, cores often remain in the liner (which makes e.g. optical scanning useless) and are later opened in laboratories. Core or at least core catcher sample description is mandatory for projects drilling core.
ICDP already offers a few devices that you can request and use during the drilling. That would need to be included in the costs and timeframe of the project.
PIs are obliged to publish Operational Reports, which have already some level of standardization. Since ICDP projects are much more diverse than IODP projects, further standardization as in IODP would not be helpful.
However, there is room for improvement and ICDP is striving to get better reports. This depends not only on current efforts but also on enhanced funding by ICDP and other contributing parties.
Samples and data created by an ICDP-funded project belong to the project and not ICDP. In return to project funding, we expect to be acknowledged or included in your publication.
We need to have a stronger data management plan that conforms to FAIR principles
ICDP will consider making a data management plan mandatory in ICDP full proposals and provide a template.
Formalized sample allocation procedure. Currently, there is too much power with a single person (PI, curator...) ,making a decision on their own. Gatekeepers exist!
How about a sample request management module?
That is in the hands of the project. We recommend to have a data and sample manager in every project, that stays with the data/samples even after the project has ended. Or the project has to organize that with the core repository. Sample Requests should always be decided upon by the PI-team.